November 17, 2026
Journal Article
Evaluation of Data-Independent Acquisition-Based Phosphoproteomics Analysis in Mammalian and Bacterial Systems
Abstract
Recent advancements in data-independent acquisition (DIA) workflows have greatly increased the depth and throughput of mass spectrometry-based proteomics analysis. However, many of these advancements, such as high-throughput acquisition using the Orbitrap Astral, remain under characterized for phosphoproteomics analysis, particularly in bacteria which have fewer protein phosphorylation events. We compared and evaluated the impact of instrument/analysis time (Orbitrap Astral, 15 minute; Orbitrap Exploris, 90 minute), data analysis tools (DIA NN 1.9.2, DIA NN 2.0, FragPipe, Spectronaut), and library search strategy (spectral library versus library free) on phosphoproteome identification and quantification using the human MCF 7 cell line and the Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) H37Rv strain. The 15-minute Astral analysis yielded 7-24% more phosphopeptides in comparison to a 90-minute Exploris acquisition method across all data analysis tools except for Spectronaut (~4% decrease), demonstrating a substantial advantage in throughput. Within the Astral analysis, Spectronaut provided the highest phosphoproteome coverage, whereas DIA-NN 1.9.2, DIA-NN 2.0, and FragPipe demonstrated less variations in quantification. We further evaluated high-throughput Astral analysis in Mtb phosphoproteome and compared library-free and spectral-library search strategies, where we observed equivalent phosphopeptide coverage yet different profiles between library-free and spectral-library searches across all analysis tools. Finally, we investigated the influence of data analysis tools on downstream statistical analysis. Although the significance of phosphosites varied among the tools, the direction of fold-change between two independent Mtb lysate groups was mostly consistent. We expect this work will inform workflow selection for phosphoproteomics studies using a DIA approach, especially for analyzing biological samples with low phosphorylation frequencies.Published: November 17, 2026