PNNL

Abstract

Modifications to vertical barrier screens (VBS) and the addition of concrete corbels to improve passage conditions for juvenile salmonids in the gatewells of Bonneville Dam’s second powerhouse (B2) were completed prior to the 2024 passage season. To evaluate the effectiveness of those modifications, PNNL carried out a post construction evaluation to contrast fish condition and mortality between two turbine unit operational ranges within the peak efficiency range. A block-treatment study design was implemented in 2024 to contrast descaling and mortality of juvenile salmonids sampled in the juvenile fish facility following exposure to turbine operations (middle versus upper 1% peak efficiency range) during spring and summer passage periods. In spring, 1.96% of juvenile salmonids sampled during mid-1% operations were descaled and 0.46% were mortalities. Of those sampled during upper 1% unit operations in spring, 2.90% were descaled and 0.95% were mortalities. Although these differences appeared to be meaningful, substantial exceedances of the upper 1% limit occurred during two treatment blocks of the spring study period. Fish collected during the upper 1% treatment of these two blocks experienced substantially higher rates of descaling and mortality compared to those collected during mid-1% treatments. Censoring these two upper 1% samples from the spring study period resulted in upper 1% descaling and mortality rates that were statistically similar to those from the mid-1% treatment. During the summer study period, 0.99% of juveniles sampled during mid-1% operations were descaled and 0.33% suffered mortality; these rates were significantly lower than the descaling (2.80%) and mortality (1.73%) rates observed during upper 1% treatments. Comparing the results from the 2024 study to those from the historical (2008–2013) baseline of unmodified units revealed that the descaling and mortality rates observed during upper 1% operations in spring 2024 were near the upper end of the historic range observed for mid-1% operations. Spring 2024 upper 1% descaling and mortality rates were below, or well below the median of historical mid and upper 1% (combined) rates, which suggests that the modifications have had a positive effect. Summer 2024 upper 1% descaling and mortality rates were at or above the top of the range of historical mid 1% and above or well above the median of historical mid and upper 1% (combined) rates. It is important to keep in mind that 2024 is a single year when considering these comparisons. Additional study could help confirm these results or seek a level of operation that achieves the desired outcomes for fish.