September 22, 2026
Journal Article

Structural Incorporation into Goethite Fractionates Rare Earth Elements

Abstract

Up to 20% of rare earth elements (REEs) in ion adsorption deposits (IADs) are associated with iron oxide minerals, primarily goethite. Often termed “non-extractable”, goethite-hosted REEs are thought to be structurally incorporated into the mineral lattice. The large mismatch in size and charge density between REEs and Fe3+, however, makes direct substitution energetically unfavorable. To determine REE compatibility with and incorporation into goethite on the atomic level, we used X-ray pair distribution function analysis (PDF) and LIII-edge extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy. The compatibility of REEs with goethite and the precursor ferrihydrite (FH) is Lu = Yb >> Dy > Nd for both phases. Nd and Dy primarily form secondary amorphous phases, with

Published: September 22, 2026

Citation

Mergelsberg S.T., A.J. Kugler, E. Flynn, D. Song, E.J. Bylaska, J.G. Catalano, and E.S. Ilton. 2025. Structural Incorporation into Goethite Fractionates Rare Earth Elements. RSC Advances 15, no. 35:28815-28826. PNNL-SA-212073. doi:10.1039/D5RA04022A