November 17, 2026
Journal Article

A cross-site comparison of ecosystem- and plot-scale methane fluxes across multiple timescales

Abstract

Wetland and upland ecosystems play significant but opposing roles in the global methane (CH4) budget, acting as natural sources and sinks, respectively. Two of the most common approaches for measuring CH4 fluxes (FCH4) are chambers, which capture temporally intermittent, fine-scale spatial heterogeneity (ca. 1 m2), and eddy covariance (EC) towers, which cover a larger area (ca. 100-10000 m2) at a longer term. Although chamber and EC observations have been combined in various syntheses and databases to estimate CH4 budgets, a unified cross-site evaluation of FCH4 estimates at plot and ecosystem scales is lacking. As a first step toward a systematic spatiotemporal scaling of EC tower and chamber footprints, we quantified the differences between site-level aggregate FCH4 (EC vs chamber; ?FCH4) from ten wetland and upland sites at half-hourly, hourly, daily, weekly, monthly, and annual timescales. We found that ecosystem-scale median FCH4 was consistently higher than plot-scale FCH4 at all temporal scales, with the smallest difference at daily timescale (multi-site median ?FCH4: 1.36 nmol m-2 s-1; ~104% higher ecosystem-scale than plot-scale FCH4) and largest at annual scales (2.58 nmol m-2 s-1; ~87% higher ecosystem-scale than plot-scale FCH4). In general, the agreement between ecosystem- and plot-scale FCH4 decreased with finer temporal resolution (from Spearman ?=0.95 at annual scale to ?=0.65 at half-hourly scale), while ?FCH4 variation was greatest at daily-to-annual scales. Key environmental predictors of ?FCH4 included plot-scale spatial heterogeneity, dominant vegetation type, vapor pressure deficit, atmospheric pressure, and friction velocity at the daily and monthly scales. Wind direction was a significant predictor only at the monthly scale, suggesting EC footprint effects. These findings suggest accounting for variation in EC footprint extent, chamber measurement placement and artifacts is key to reconciling multi-scale FCH4 observations in diverse ecosystems and refining CH4 budgets.

Published: November 17, 2026

Citation

Maatta T., A.R. Desai, M. Ueyama, R. Vargas, E. Ward, Z. Zhang, and G. Bohrer, et al. 2026. A cross-site comparison of ecosystem- and plot-scale methane fluxes across multiple timescales. Biogeosciences 23, no. 13:4379–4445. PNNL-SA-217784. doi:10.5194/bg-23-4379-2026

Research topics