September 22, 2026
Journal Article

A Cautionary Tale: Failure of the Valence CASSCF to Describe the Hallmark of Hydrogen Bonding

Abstract

Valence CASSCF (vCAS) calculations for the hydrogen-bonded (H2O)2, (HF)2, and HF–H2O dimers fail to predict the lengthening of the hydrogen donor bond and the corresponding red shift in the donor bond vibrational stretching frequency. Analysis of the active orbitals in the vCAS calculation reveals that one of the weakly occupied orbitals in each dimer is used to correlate the electrons in the acceptor lone pairs rather than those in the donor bonding orbitals. This has significant implications for subsequent treatments of the dynamical correlation that are based on the vCAS wavefunction.

Published: September 22, 2026

Citation

Nguyen L.H., T.H. Dunning, and S.S. Xantheas. 2026. A Cautionary Tale: Failure of the Valence CASSCF to Describe the Hallmark of Hydrogen Bonding. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 22, no. 13:6283–6289. PNNL-SA-222871. doi:10.1021/acs.jctc.6c00606

Research topics