PNNL

Abstract

The island rule predicts gigantism or dwarfism in body size of island species relative to their mainland counterparts. However, whether other functional traits shift, and whether trait-trait associations on islands differ between species and community levels remains unclear. We measured 13 carbon- and water-related functional traits in 37 shared tree species across eastern Chinese islands and 66 nearby mainland plots. We examined species-level trait value shifts and associations under the island rule, and compared trait associations between species and communities. Most size-related, wood-anatomical, and hydraulic traits shifted on islands, with large values decreasing and small values increasing; yet their associations remained stable, aligning with the global trait spectrum and trait-trait coevolution. This stability, despite trait value shifts, suggests evolutionary integration of functional strategies. In contrast, island community-scale trait associations diverged from shared species-level patterns and sometimes reversed, such as positive relationships between wood density and resource-acquisitive traits. Community-level trait associations were stronger on islands, likely reflecting constrained environmental filtering and migration limitation. These contrasting patterns suggest that dominant species can restructure trait associations at the community level, with implications for ecosystem functioning and carbon storage, thereby advancing understanding of plant trait strategies in island systems.